Best Practices for Building a Successful Programmatic Campaign 

Best Practices for Building a Successful Programmatic Campaign

August 16, 2023

Launching an effective programmatic ad campaign requires more than just a leap of faith – it demands a calculated approach that aligns creativity with analytics. Whether you're a seasoned marketing pro or an inquisitive newcomer, it’s important to carefully map out the steps required to deliver a personalized experience for customers while achieving desired outcomes. Here's how to get started!   

Understand your target audience 

Building a programmatic strategy begins with a deep understanding of your target audience. This entails a detailed exploration of various characteristics such as job title or function and geographical location, as well as factors such as industry, seniority, or company size. In addition, it’s crucial to trace the sites or apps these users frequent, identifying the types of content that they respond to or interact with, and recognizing patterns in similar audiences pulled from on-site traffic. An example of this would be targeting subscribers of a newsletter or association members interested in a particular industry. Once these parameters are established, that data is used to identify the users who meet the criteria and will be served an ad.  

Filter target domains

One of the tools that comes with programmatic is the option to set up either a blacklist or whitelist. A whitelist is a list of domains and apps that are the only ones allowed to display your ad, while a blacklist allows all domains/apps to host your ad, except the ones you specify. Since programmatic ads target a user based on their characteristics and behavior rather than the context of a page, you have less insight into where exactly your ads are appearing which leaves you at risk of landing on inappropriate sites. Black and whitelists ensure your ad isn’t showing up on sites that are spam or inappropriate and can allow you to more specifically target desired audiences. 

Choosing which kind of list to implement depends on your targeting goals. The internet is riddled with MFA (made for advertising) media – a whitelist limits the selection of hosts to good quality, curated sites. A blacklist is usually used when you want maximum reach while keeping out obvious spam and avoiding risky variables. For example, companies like Disney would likely use a blacklist, but a medical device manufacturer (B2B company) would opt for a whitelist since they have a more niche audience and industry targets.  

Choose a data vendor 

A crucial step in crafting an effective programmatic strategy is selecting a data vendor that has a high-quality way of identifying people based on your desired data attributes. The options for Demand-Side Platforms (DSPs) are vast, ranging from those tailored to specific channels and formats to those allowing for a more adaptable approach. The efficacy of your strategy is closely tied to the functionalities your chosen DSP can facilitate. A broader spectrum of capabilities directly translates to heightened potential for your programmatic ad endeavors. Secondly, a choice emerges between aggregate vendors and trusted-party vendors, each with their own advantages.  

It's important to note that in an era progressively distancing itself from cookies, the backbone of programmatic lies in data derived from consumer consent. This key detail is set to become of great importance as we navigate the shift toward a cookie-less future. By meticulously considering all your options and aligning them with your goals, you pave the way for dynamic programmatic advertising. 

Create a compelling message 

A key aspect of earning unwavering attention is creating captivating and engaging ads, because the intrinsic worth of your efforts relies upon the effectiveness of the advertisements themselves. These ads serve as the initial point of contact between your brand and your audience and should spark an immediate and lasting impact. 

A variety of ad types are available, each designed to resonate with distinct segments of your audience. Classic banner ads seamlessly blend into web layouts, grabbing attention with concise messaging and eye-catching visuals. Rich media ads, on the other hand, are embedded, interactive elements that engage and immerse the viewer. The dynamic potential of video ads can’t be underestimated, either. They have the ability to unfold narratives and evoke emotional connections. And finally, the subtlety of native advertising through the use of social media platforms harmoniously integrates into its environment, delivering a non-disruptive experience. 

While visuals are important for grabbing initial attention, the effectiveness of your ads truly lies in the message. You want to ensure that your campaign includes a variety of messaging for all stages of the sales funnel since you won't know exactly who your ad will reach or where they’ll be in the buying process. Once you gain more insights on how familiar users are with your brand, you can begin grouping them and retargeting them with more specific messaging, driving them to the next stage of the funnel.  

Set goals 

Starting the journey of building a strong programmatic campaign entails detailing your specific plan and defining the objectives. The foundation of this planning rests on a comprehensive understanding of your benchmarks and the resources at your disposal. Start by assessing factors such as existing website traffic, the cost of acquiring new customers, the demographics of your current audiences, and the engagement across various channels and communities. The insights derived from these metrics will serve as the baseline for determining your potential budget allocation, as well as shaping the core ad formats and channels for your campaign. 

Amidst setting up this framework, identifying precise, measurable goals is essential. The spectrum of possibilities spans from elevating sales and enhancing brand visibility to driving increased traffic to your website or app, all while curbing the cost per user acquisition and re-engaging past clients. The core of these goals should lie in devising strategic measures to accurately gauge their success rate. The effectiveness of your strategy hinges on the ability to precisely measure the progress towards these goals.  

Track success

Harnessing the power of data and key performance indicators (KPIs) stands as a critical step in the development of an effective programmatic campaign. As campaigns run their course, these metrics provide the compass guiding your success. When it comes to direct campaigns, online auctions act as insightful metrics, shedding light on the efficacy of your targeting and bidding strategies. Beyond the straightforward numbers, tracking social media responses and heightened website traffic offers a more detailed picture of brand awareness. These nuanced indicators gauge the resonance of your message and the ripple effect across digital platforms. Among these performance benchmarks, win rate stands out, encapsulating the ratio of successful bids to the total attempts, a metric indicative of your campaign's success in securing favorable outcomes. By closely navigating these data points, your programmatic advertising strategy gains the advantage required to adapt and ultimately thrive. 

Make adjustments 

Data tracking and vigilance lead to a need for adaptability – a trait that ensures your strategy remains attuned to the evolving needs and trends of your target audience. A strategy molded by real-time data and informed by the changing behaviors of your audience can pivot swiftly, optimizing outcomes and maintaining relevance. The journey doesn't end with the initial deployment; it evolves as you gather additional information about your consumers and their behavior.  

As your campaign progresses, you’ll be armed with newfound insights. The smart move is to fine-tune and adjust your ads as you go, ensuring they resonate more deeply and with the evolving behaviors of your clients. In essence, building an adaptive programmatic advertising strategy is a continuous cycle of assessment, adaptation, and optimization that ensures your campaign stays ahead of the curve and delivers impactful results. 



The success of your programmatic campaign hinges on the partnership of creativity and data-driven precision. Craft tailored strategies, align with adept data vendors, create engaging content, and adapt dynamically – all with the goal of leaving a lasting imprint on consumers. Now you can continue your programmatic journey with confidence and purpose. Looking for more? Always feel free to reach out to learn more about digital marketing solutions 



Share This:

Newsletter Sign Up

Receive regular updates in your inbox.
Sign up for our newsletter!

Subscribe Here!

Discover more blog articles

Explore the latest B2B topics and gain insight to adapt best practices for success and help grow your business.


Predictive AI tools havegiven businesses access to revolutionary decision-making and forecasting. The key to achieving reliable insights and accurate...


Tacos and margaritas, peanut butter and jelly, Travis Kelce and Taylor Swift – there’s nothing we love more than a perfect pair. But when it comes to...


An estimated 4.4 billion people use email, making it the primary communication channel for many businesses. However, with increasing spam threats,...


Ready to get started?
How can we help market your business?

Complete the form below and we’ll get in touch with you right away.